6,000 stories, no named newsroom: questions mount over Winchester Gazette

Cartoon · AI-generated
An investigation into the anonymous website found disputed interviews, questions about AI use and unresolved links to a local political figure, as its rapid output drew scrutiny.
In Winchester, Virginia, an anonymous local news website became the subject of an investigation into who was producing its stories, how they were reported and what happens when established local journalism retreats.
The Winchester Gazette began publishing in 2023, covering crime, council business and community events. It offered readers a free alternative as The Winchester Star reduced its staff and other local media resources dwindled. The Gazette did not identify its reporters, editors, owners or funders, and it claimed an audience of about 11,000 visitors a month. Its emergence came amid a wider decline: Northwestern University’s Medill School of Journalism found that 213 US counties had no local news source in 2025, while a further 1,524 had only one. [3], [5], [7]
The Virginia Center for Investigative Journalism at WHRO began examining the site after a tip sent to the newsroom later appeared almost word for word in a Gazette story. Freelance reporters Jaysun Silver and Laura Thompson then contacted people quoted in other articles. Several said they had not spoken to the Gazette, although the publication later maintained that the interviews had taken place and said it stood by its work. [2], [3]
Public-records requests and interviews brought further questions. A former Gazette freelancer, Milly Mullins, provided reporters with her contract and internal messages. She described assignments to attend road collisions and collect personal details about those involved; the contract included penalties for disclosing internal information. Mullins also alleged that artificial intelligence was used to produce stories, a claim the Gazette did not address directly. These accounts formed part of a broader investigation into the site’s practices, rather than resolving how its reporting was produced. [3], [5]
The reporters also examined company filings and sought to establish who stood behind the Gazette. Their investigation traced Commonwealth Media, the company associated with the site’s launch, to records involving Winchester lawyer Carroll “Beau” Correll and an elderly relative. Correll, who chaired the Winchester Republican Committee and served on the city planning commission, denied owning or exercising editorial control over the website. The investigation did not settle questions about the Gazette’s ownership or the extent of any involvement by Correll. [3], [5]
The reporting relied on repeated planning discussions, visits to Winchester, interviews and checks against public records. The team also sought responses from the Gazette, whose replies did not answer questions about the use of AI or agree to an in-person meeting. By the final stages of the investigation, reporters had found that the site had published about 6,000 stories in three years, an output that drew attention to the scale of its operation despite the absence of a publicly identifiable newsroom. [2], [3]
Publication prompted calls from elected officials for Correll to leave his public roles. Winchester City Council President Corey Sullivan, a Republican, urged him to step down from the planning commission and Republican committee; Democratic council members also called for his departure from the commission. Correll rejected Sullivan’s request, while another Republican council member called for transparency without explicitly demanding his resignation. The dispute remained unresolved, and Sullivan acknowledged that removing Correll before his term ended would require meeting a legal threshold. [4]
The case illustrates how a little-known outlet can attract an audience where residents have fewer established sources of local reporting. Virginia has seen newspaper closures and staffing cuts as part of a broader contraction in local media, while national research shows many communities have little or no local news coverage. The Gazette investigation raised questions about accountability and reporting standards, but the central facts about its ownership and editorial control remained unsettled. [6], [7]
Inspired by headline at: [1]
Sources by paragraph: - Paragraph 1: [2], [3] - Paragraph 2: [3], [5], [7] - Paragraph 3: [2], [3] - Paragraph 4: [3], [5] - Paragraph 5: [2], [3] - Paragraph 6: [4] - Paragraph 7: [6], [7]
Source: Noah Wire Services · Original