All flashes and flames: the data doesn't support a publishers' war on bots
At the Flashes & Flames AI forum, publishers made the case for controlling who can copy their work. Five forecasts test what that would deliver for the trade.

Cartoon · AI-generated
One seat was missing from the discussion at Stationers’ Hall on 18 November. Paul Hood of the House of Commons joined Tami Hoffman of the Guardian, Emily Shelley of the Press Association, Paul Shanley of the Associated Press and Sajeeda Merali of the PPA. Nobody on the panel spoke for the reader who sends software to read on their behalf. Programme
From the stage, the proposal sounded orderly. Identify each visitor, decide which uses to permit, then charge for access. The first difficulty comes at the door: what happens when the visitor declines to give a name?
The Associated Press already sells its journalism in a form that machines can read. Its revenue director was on the panel. What would it mean for publishers to treat a bot as a potential customer?
The big thinking Every Editor’s Pick →
Previous Editor’s Picks & selected reading.
Future’s AI lab needs to count the editing
HarperCollins’ TikTok sales are growing. The missing figure is profit
The Guardian gets carbon removal wrong. Why aren't tier one papers using tier one data?
Carbon Brief’s paid community puts a price on journalists’ time
Paper mills are changing course. Publishers need a second option
The newswire All the latest →
What’s moving in publishing.
Reporting from Noah Wire-
People & Skills
Who signs the Baltimore Sun’s AI cartoons?
The Sun has credited its editorial staff collectively for an AI-generated cartoon. That tells readers how it was made, but leaves a question about who supplied the judgement.
An illustration in the Baltimore Sun’s 4 September edition credited the paper’s editorial staff and disclosed that they had used AI tools. The collective credit draws attention to a choice other publishers will face: when a newsroom generates an image, whose editorial judgement is the reader being asked to trust?
Read the full story → -
Strategy
From free daily to AI: Diario Occidente’s unfinished reinvention
Make sense of what’s next.
A weekly briefing for people shaping the future of publishing.
More from the wire
- AI & Technology David Sinclair’s blog editor drafts alt text. He still checks what it claims
- People & Skills AI could bring books to radio, but broadcasters still need to direct the story
- Policy & Rights Newsmax says AI is cutting article production time as licensing grows
- AI & Technology Apopka Chief sets rules for AI use, with journalists accountable for every story
Noah Wire. Every publication can have its own wire.
Build yours →The changing business
WSJ tests an AI tool that can suggest an ad plan in about an hour
The Journal’s revenue chief says a plan normally takes four or five hours. The tool is still being tested, and the publisher keeps people in charge of branded content.
After cutting 90 staff, McClatchy plans an AI-native newsroom
McClatchy is weaving automated tools into editorial and business operations after major newsroom cuts, as staff challenge how AI-reworked stories are produced, credited and disclosed.
The deal went quiet. What did the buyer need?
AI could help publishers win more of the business they already pitch. The bigger prize is finding out what customers would pay for next.


The publishing agenda.
A few stories to start with.
Follow a section for the full picture.
Strategy

LVMH’s news will appear in ChatGPT. Will readers click through?
The deal covers newsroom tools and links from ChatGPT answers to original reporting. The companies disclosed neither the price nor what those links are expected to deliver.
- Strategy The Guardian gets carbon removal wrong. Why aren't tier one papers using tier one data?
- Strategy Paper mills are changing course. Publishers need a second option
Audiences
African media delegation sees AI tools at People’s Daily, with journalists’ role in focus
- Audiences Newsrooms are installing AI. The harder task is changing how they work
- Audiences Newsquest’s subscriber growth puts the renewal test in focus
Revenue
HarperCollins’ TikTok sales are growing. The missing figure is profit
- Revenue Fashion.at tested a subscription offer on a reader who doesn’t exist
- Revenue Carbon Brief’s paid community puts a price on journalists’ time
AI & Technology
David Sinclair’s blog editor drafts alt text. He still checks what it claims
- AI & Technology Apopka Chief sets rules for AI use, with journalists accountable for every story
- AI & Technology Future’s AI lab needs to count the editing
Platforms & Discovery
Retracted paper exposes how hidden prompts can sway AI peer review
- Platforms & Discovery Crypto publishers put AI in the byline as newsroom cuts continue
- Platforms & Discovery How Jane Friedman uses AI to reclaim time for her writing business
Policy & Rights
Newsmax says AI is cutting article production time as licensing grows
- Policy & Rights The Daily 51 says AI drafts the news and its publisher decides what runs
- Policy & Rights Schibsted uses audience data to lure back ad budgets from Meta
Products & Formats
Illinois nonprofit accuses AI-assisted rival of reusing its reporting and photos
- Products & Formats CNBC weighs AI summaries and live transcripts to extend its journalism
- Products & Formats Newsroom trials broaden Planet Detroit’s civic action tool beyond meeting matches
People & Skills
AI could bring books to radio, but broadcasters still need to direct the story
- People & Skills iMore Labs plans AI drafting tests with editors in charge
- People & Skills Advance Local builds a safer route from AI prototypes to live newsroom tools
Local & Specialist Publishing
Wisconsin Watch wants AI answers to lead readers back to local news
- Local & Specialist Publishing 6,000 stories, no named newsroom: questions mount over Winchester Gazette
- Local & Specialist Publishing US newsroom unions seek contract limits as AI tools spread
Noah Wire. Every publication can have its own wire.
Build yours →Noah Wire. Every publication can have its own wire.
Build yours →Noah Wire. Every publication can have its own wire.
Build yours →Make sense of what's next.
A weekly briefing for people shaping the future of publishing.
Free. Email requests are handled by our team.