TP The business of what comes next Thursday 19 November 2026 · updated 05:45 Get the weekly briefing
Tomorrow’sPublisher.
Editor’s Pick Policy & Rights

All flashes and flames: the data doesn't support a publishers' war on bots

At Flashes & Flames' AI forum this week, a panel of publishers and policymakers made the case for identifying bots, shutting out the unlicensed ones and asking Parliament for a law. Tomorrow's Publisher tested that case against the evidence

A doorman stops a paying reader at a short velvet rope.

Cartoon · AI-generated

Inside the Editor’s Pick

A subscriber pays for a news site, then asks an AI assistant to search its archive and prepare a briefing. The site refuses the assistant. The reader has paid, and has been told that the tool they chose to read with is not welcome. Inside the trade this is called protecting journalism. The customer has a shorter word for it.

That reader was missing from the main stage at Stationers' Hall on 18 November. The session, "AI, public policy and the platforms", put five people in front of a sold-out room: Paul Hood of the House of Commons, Tami Hoffman of the Guardian, Emily Shelley of the Press Association, Paul Shanley of the Associated Press and Sajeeda Merali of the PPA. That is Parliament, a national newspaper, two news agencies and a trade body. Nobody on the platform builds an agent, runs a search product or speaks for the people who now send software to read on their behalf. It was a panel of sellers discussing how to make buyers behave. Programme

Their plan had four parts: identify the bots, decide which uses to permit, block the rest and charge for access. It was received warmly, as it always is. The publishing trade leans heavily towards protection, and it is surrounded by advisers who are paid to tell it to bolt the doors. This piece takes the plan at its word and checks each part against the evidence.

Continue reading the full article
· 9 min read · Ivan Massow

The big thinking Every Editor’s Pick →

Previous Editor’s Picks & selected reading.

The newswire All the latest →

What’s moving in publishing.

Reporting from Noah Wire
  1. Editorial cartoon accompanying: Wisconsin Watch to test whether AI assistants can cite local reporting
    Local & Specialist Publishing

    Wisconsin Watch to test whether AI assistants can cite local reporting

    A $35,000 Reynolds Journalism Institute grant will fund an open-source connector to give compatible AI tools access to Wisconsin Watch’s archive, with a public trial due in early 2027.

    A $35,000 Reynolds Journalism Institute grant will support a trial of whether AI assistants can use local reporting more accurately and make its origins clear. The project brings together journalism technology network Hacks/Hackers and Wisconsin Watch, a nonprofit investigative newsroom serving communities across Wisconsin. Its central tool will be an open-source Model Context Protocol server, or connector, designed…

    Read the full story → 19 Nov 2026 · 2 min read
  2. Editorial cartoon accompanying: Crypto publishers put AI in the byline as newsroom cuts continue
    Platforms & Discovery

    Crypto publishers put AI in the byline as newsroom cuts continue

    19 Nov 2026 · 3 min read

More from the wire

Advertisement · Noah

The changing business

Explore the sections

The publishing agenda.

A few stories to start with.
Follow a section for the full picture.

Strategy

Editorial cartoon accompanying: LVMH titles enter ChatGPT as OpenAI deal leaves traffic and safeguards in question
More Strategy

Audiences

More Audiences

Revenue

More Revenue

AI & Technology

More AI & Technology

Platforms & Discovery

More Platforms
Advertisement · Noah
Advertisement · Noah
Advertisement · Noah

Make sense of what's next.

A weekly briefing for people shaping the future of publishing.

Free. Email requests are handled by our team.