All flashes and flames: the data doesn't support a publishers' war on bots
At Flashes & Flames' AI forum this week, a panel of publishers and policymakers made the case for identifying bots, shutting out the unlicensed ones and asking Parliament for a law. Tomorrow's Publisher tested that case against the evidence

Cartoon · AI-generated
A subscriber pays for a news site, then asks an AI assistant to search its archive and prepare a briefing. The site refuses the assistant. The reader has paid, and has been told that the tool they chose to read with is not welcome. Inside the trade this is called protecting journalism. The customer has a shorter word for it.
That reader was missing from the main stage at Stationers' Hall on 18 November. The session, "AI, public policy and the platforms", put five people in front of a sold-out room: Paul Hood of the House of Commons, Tami Hoffman of the Guardian, Emily Shelley of the Press Association, Paul Shanley of the Associated Press and Sajeeda Merali of the PPA. That is Parliament, a national newspaper, two news agencies and a trade body. Nobody on the platform builds an agent, runs a search product or speaks for the people who now send software to read on their behalf. It was a panel of sellers discussing how to make buyers behave. Programme
Their plan had four parts: identify the bots, decide which uses to permit, block the rest and charge for access. It was received warmly, as it always is. The publishing trade leans heavily towards protection, and it is surrounded by advisers who are paid to tell it to bolt the doors. This piece takes the plan at its word and checks each part against the evidence.
The big thinking Every Editor’s Pick →
Previous Editor’s Picks & selected reading.
HarperCollins’ TikTok sales are growing. The missing figure is profit
The Guardian gets carbon removal wrong. Why aren't tier one papers using tier one data?
Carbon Brief’s paid community puts a price on journalists’ time
Paper mills are changing course. Publishers need a second option
The FT has shut AI out of its newsroom. So we ran one of its flagship features through ours
The newswire All the latest →
What’s moving in publishing.
Reporting from Noah Wire-
Platforms & Discovery
Crypto publishers put AI in the byline as newsroom cuts continue
Decrypt and CoinDesk openly label AI-linked content, while reported redundancies across crypto newsrooms raise questions about how automation and staff cuts intersect , without proving one caused the other.
Cryptocurrency publishers are increasingly making artificial intelligence visible in their coverage as the sector contends with sustained pressure on newsroom jobs. Press Gazette’s investigation, introduced in its newsletter by Rob Waugh, describes AI use as part of a wider shift in a specialist media market that expanded during the crypto boom but has since become more difficult for journalists. The newsletter…
Read the full story → -
Audiences
African media delegation sees AI tools at People’s Daily, with journalists’ role in focus
Make sense of what’s next.
A weekly briefing for people shaping the future of publishing.
More from the wire
- Local & Specialist Publishing 6,000 stories, no named newsroom: questions mount over Winchester Gazette
- People & Skills iMore Labs to test AI-assisted drafting against Future’s editorial rules
- Platforms & Discovery How Jane Friedman uses AI to reclaim time for her writing business
- AI & Technology W.TEC trains NAN journalists to use AI without outsourcing verification
Noah Wire. Every publication can have its own wire.
Build yours →The changing business
LVMH media group brings OpenAI tools into newsrooms and ChatGPT answers
The agreement will give staff access to AI tools for tasks such as document searches and preliminary translation, while making the group’s journalism more visible in ChatGPT answers. Key commercial terms and details of any use of its conten
Newsrooms are installing AI. The harder task is changing how they work
Publishers are rolling out systems to automate routine work, but research suggests few have changed roles or workflows. Adapting to AI will take more than giving journalists new tools.
The deal went quiet. What did the buyer need?
AI could help publishers win more of the business they already pitch. The bigger prize is finding out what customers would pay for next.


The publishing agenda.
A few stories to start with.
Follow a section for the full picture.
Strategy

LVMH titles enter ChatGPT as OpenAI deal leaves traffic and safeguards in question
The partnership gives LVMH newsroom staff access to OpenAI tools and lets ChatGPT draw on its publications, but the financial terms, referral traffic and protections for confidential material remain unclear.
- Strategy The Guardian gets carbon removal wrong. Why aren't tier one papers using tier one data?
- Strategy Paper mills are changing course. Publishers need a second option
Audiences
Newsquest’s subscriber growth puts the renewal test in focus
- Audiences Young voters swing to Democrats, but online right’s decline is harder to prove
- Audiences Frammer AI to turn BBC India newsroom footage into digital video
Revenue
HarperCollins’ TikTok sales are growing. The missing figure is profit
- Revenue Fashion.at’s AI audience twin sketches subscribers, but cannot predict their response
- Revenue Carbon Brief’s paid community puts a price on journalists’ time
AI & Technology
W.TEC trains NAN journalists to use AI without outsourcing verification
- AI & Technology APEC press centre AI gives journalists access to a newsroom, not just a chatbot
- AI & Technology The FT has shut AI out of its newsroom. So we ran one of its flagship features through ours
Platforms & Discovery
How Jane Friedman uses AI to reclaim time for her writing business
- Platforms & Discovery HellerWeather adds AI drafts for more than 20 forecast-led formats
- Platforms & Discovery Gateway Pundit’s AI tests raise accuracy concerns, but do not prove political censorship
Policy & Rights
The Daily 51 puts a human publisher at the end of its AI newsroom
- Policy & Rights Schibsted uses audience data to lure back ad budgets from Meta
- Policy & Rights North Wales newsrooms get £90,526 to test AI leads and expand community coverage
Products & Formats
CNBC weighs AI summaries and live transcripts to extend its journalism
- Products & Formats Newsroom trials broaden Planet Detroit’s civic action tool beyond meeting matches
- Products & Formats SPH Media looks to plug into AI channels without losing its place in the news
People & Skills
iMore Labs to test AI-assisted drafting against Future’s editorial rules
- People & Skills Advance Local builds a safer route from AI prototypes to live newsroom tools
- People & Skills Digital Sahafat reaches 4,000 as Pakistan weighs AI’s place in journalism
Local & Specialist Publishing
6,000 stories, no named newsroom: questions mount over Winchester Gazette
- Local & Specialist Publishing US newsroom unions seek contract limits as AI tools spread
- Local & Specialist Publishing Yahoo becomes first licensee of collective AI content scheme
Noah Wire. Every publication can have its own wire.
Build yours →Noah Wire. Every publication can have its own wire.
Build yours →Noah Wire. Every publication can have its own wire.
Build yours →Make sense of what's next.
A weekly briefing for people shaping the future of publishing.
Free. Email requests are handled by our team.