TP The business of what comes next Monday 16 November 2026 · updated 23:03 Get the weekly briefing
Tomorrow’sPublisher.
Editor’s Pick Strategy

The Guardian gets carbon removal wrong. Why aren't tier one papers using tier one data?

Think Negative challenged us to check the Guardian's reporting from COP31. We found carbon stored in fizzy drinks, a headline number attached to the wrong technology, and a question that applies to every publisher.

An executive in a red waistcoat pours a fizzy drink from a blue CO₂ bottle as gas bubbles escape into the air. A colleague in blue watches. Caption: The carbon is safely stored.

Cartoon · AI-generated

Inside the Editor’s Pick

On 16 November the Guardian's Oliver Milman reported on a push to give carbon dioxide removal greater recognition at the COP31 climate talks. [1] Think Negative, an independent organisation advocating carbon dioxide removal, sent Tomorrow's Publisher a challenge: check whether the evidence supports the story.

We usually reserve this sort of attention for the Financial Times, so a change of target was welcome. We took the article back to its sources: the IPCC, the State of Carbon Dioxide Removal report, UNEP and the companies named. The exercise produced an irony. The Guardian's piece is largely sceptical of carbon removal, yet its most striking numerical error flatters the technology it doubts. Put the figure right and direct air capture looks considerably worse than the Guardian suggested, while the case for dismissing the whole sector looks weaker.

"It is too late to just reduce emissions, we have to remove as well," Think Negative told us. [10] The organisation describes its role as bringing together the range of actors needed to deliver the removal the IPCC says is necessary. It is an advocate for that outcome, which is why we tested its arguments against original publications.

· 11 min read · Ivan Massow Read the Editor’s Pick →

The big thinking Every Editor’s Pick →

Previous Editor’s Picks & selected reading.

The newswire All the latest →

What’s moving in publishing.

Reporting from Noah Wire
  1. Editorial cartoon accompanying: Fashion.at’s AI audience twin sketches subscribers, but cannot predict their response
    Revenue

    Fashion.at’s AI audience twin sketches subscribers, but cannot predict their response

    A Gemini-powered simulation proposed audience profiles and subscription tactics for the magazine, but its fictional persona and campaign recommendations have not been tested with real readers.

    Fashion.at has used an AI-based digital-twin tool to construct a hypothetical portrait of its readership and simulate how that audience might respond to an annual subscription offer. The exercise produced a fictional figure, Elena B., a 36-year-old Vienna-based curator, intended to represent a broader group aged 28 to 48 rather than any identifiable subscriber. Fashion.at says the tool was developed by Dr Josef…

    Read the full story → 16 Nov 2026 · 3 min read
  2. Editorial cartoon accompanying: LVMH titles enter ChatGPT as OpenAI deal leaves traffic and safeguards in question
    Strategy

    LVMH titles enter ChatGPT as OpenAI deal leaves traffic and safeguards in question

    16 Nov 2026 · 2 min read

More from the wire

Advertisement · Noah

The changing business

Explore the sections

The publishing agenda.

A few stories to start with.
Follow a section for the full picture.

Strategy

A publisher holds an empty plate behind a bolted door while a delivery worker waits outside with bread. The caption reads “Excellent. Nothing gets through.”
More Strategy

Audiences

More Audiences

Revenue

More Revenue

AI & Technology

More AI & Technology

Platforms & Discovery

More Platforms
Advertisement · Noah
Advertisement · Noah
Advertisement · Noah

Make sense of what's next.

A weekly briefing for people shaping the future of publishing.

Free. Email requests are handled by our team.